Theological
Schizophrenia
by
Laurence
M. Vance
Recently
by Laurence M. Vance: How
To Reduce Military Suicides
It is bad enough
that Republican warmongers like Mitt Romney, John McCain, Lindsey
Graham, and Allen West are whining about the supposed cuts to the
defense budget that are due to take place because of the failure
of the congressional "supercommittee," but it is disgusting
and shameful that a professor of practical theology and seminary
chancellor would do likewise.
The defense
"cuts," of course, are not really cuts at all, just reductions
in the rate of spending increases of the bloated defense budget.
So, who is
this Christian warmonger that is so upset about defense budget "cuts"
that he thinks they are a deeply disturbing, draconian, recklessly
dangerous, self-destructive absurdity.
He is not a
member, with Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, James Dobson, Hal Lindsey,
Cal Thomas, and Pat Boone, of the Christian
axis of evil, although he should be. He is not a Christian
killer par excellence, like Doug Giles. He is not a Christian
warmonger on steroids, like Bryan Fischer. And neither is he the
greatest
Christian warmonger of all time. That designation goes to Ellis
Washington.
He is Michael
Milton, the newly elected chancellor/CEO of Reformed Theological
Seminary in Charlotte, North Carolina. Milton holds a B.A. from
Mid-America Nazarene University, an M.Div. from Knox Theological
Seminary, and a Ph.D. from the University of Wales, Lampeter. He
is the former pastor of the First Presbyterian Church of Chattanooga,
Tennessee, in addition to founding two other churches and a Christian
school. Milton is the host and speaker on Faith
for Living, which can be seen on television and heard on radio.
He has also released three music CDs and is the author of several
books.
But perhaps
I should also note that Dr. Milton has a diploma from the Defense
Language Institute, holds a commission in the U.S. Army Reserves
as a chaplain, and was elected in 2010 by the Chief of Chaplains
to the College of Military Preachers and appointed an instructor
at the Armed Forces Chaplain School. He is also the founding director
of the Chaplain Ministries Institute in Charlotte. I also note that
on October 14, 2001, it was announced
that Reformed Theological Seminary had "been approved by the
NC SAA Program to receive the GI Bill under the provisions of Title
38 and 10, United States Code!"
Milton is a
theological schizophrenic. Schizophrenia
has been described as a mental disorder characterized by a disintegration
of thought processes and of emotional responsiveness that most commonly
manifests itself as auditory hallucinations, paranoid or bizarre
delusions, or disorganized speech and thinking.
I know of no
other way to describe Milton after reading his latest post on the
Faith for Living blog hosted by his seminary:
The failure
of the bipartisan super committee to take decisive action to reverse
the 15 trillion-dollar debt crisis this country needs from becoming
another Greece has, predictably, failed. Now the Washington blame
game begins. However, the greatest losers are the American people
and, specifically, those Americans who courageously and proudly
wear the uniform of the armed services.
As threats
of cuts are made to their very mission, our brave troops are on
the ground, in the air, and on the seas fighting, defending, and
protecting this nation from the continuing threats to our very
existence as a people. The absurd decision to tie massive cuts
to the US military as an "incentive" to force action
by the super committee was one of the biggest mistakes ever made
by Washington DC, and they have made a few recently. Of all the
things that the government does, providing a military to "defend
the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign
and domestic" just happens to be one of the clearest.
Scripture
teaches that God has ordained government for the good of man.
Civil authority, according to St. Paul, has been granted the power
of the sword to punish evil, thereby protecting the innocent:
"For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou
do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword
in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute
wrath upon him that doeth evil" (The Epistle to the Romans
13:4 KJV). The present talk of defense cuts flies in the face
of our nation’s duty and our proud heritage.
We have had
draw downs before – after WWII, after Vietnam, and after the Gulf
War, but we have never had to think about draconian reductions
while we were in the middle of a war! It is this very point that
is deeply disturbing, and recklessly dangerous. The consequences
of even the talk of such tinkering with our defenders, even if
reasonable heads prevail to stop this absurdity, will have their
consequences.
Have we not
learned our lesson? Reagan’s military build-up in the 1980s reversed
the ill-advised draw downs after Vietnam (just one front in a
larger, trans-generational Cold War) and, according to scholars
like Paul Kengor of Grove City College and the American Center
for Vision and Values, "All of these ventures [the strengthening
of defense] had the effect of demonstrating a stronger, resurgent
America, not only economically but also militarily. Suddenly,
the country that had left Vietnam no longer appeared to lack resolve"
(The Crusader: Ronald Reagan and the Fall of Communism by Dr.
Paul Kengor, HarperCollins, 2007, 82).
Kengor went
on to demonstrate that President Reagan understood that America
was still at war. According to this preeminent Reagan scholar,
his action in strengthening the military greatly contributed to
bringing down the Soviet Union. Why now, when our sacred military
members are risking their lives to fight "over there"
so we don’t fight "over here," would the president and
other congressional leaders think that it is any different? To
reduce military strength or even to talk about it as an option
is to demoralize our troops while they are literally in the midst
of a battle for our way of life.
Some may
call it treason. I would call it self-destructive. As a minister
of the gospel I would also call it irresponsible and immoral,
given that God has called our civil authorities to protect our
people against evil. May God have mercy and bless the troops who
bravely carry on their mission to defend this nation, even while
others who have taken the same oath are allegedly using the military
as pawns in a Washington election year. There are times when the
Church should speak up. Because our life and liberty is at stake,
I think that time is now.
Milton holds
to every armchair warrior, red-state fascist, reich-wing nationalist,
imperial Christian fallacy known to man.
As I mentioned
above, cutting the bloated defense budget is to Milton a deeply
disturbing, draconian, recklessly dangerous, self-destructive absurdity.
The "cuts" fly "in the face of our nation’s duty
and our proud heritage." Never mind that the real
defense budget is $1 trillion, that the United States spends
more than the rest of the world combined, and that most defense
spending is really spending on offense.
Milton idolizes
members of the military. They are our "brave troops."
They "courageously and proudly wear the uniform of the armed
services." God should "bless the troops." U.S. soldiers
are never Christian
killers, murders,
accomplices
to murder, criminals,
dupes,
mercenaries,
or part of the president’s
personal attack force willing to obey his latest command to
bomb, invade, occupy, and otherwise bring death and destruction
to any country he deems necessary. They are "our sacred military
members."
Milton is likewise
deceived about the real mission of the military. He thinks they
are "our defenders" who "defend this nation"
and protect "this nation from the continuing threats to our
very existence as a people." The government provides a military
to "defend the Constitution of the United States against all
enemies, foreign and domestic." U.S. troops "fight ‘over
there’ so we don’t fight ‘over here.’" They are "in the
midst of a battle for our way of life." But is this what the
U.S. military actually does? Unfortunately, most of what the military
does is more offense than defense, more foreign than domestic, and
more civilian than martial. I think Milton needs a course in DOD
101.
Milton says
that we are "in the middle of a war." The United States
is actually in the middle of several wars. But rather than saying
we should not cut defense because we are fighting wars, why not
examine the wars we are fighting to see if they are just, right,
and necessary? Since the undeclared, unconstitutional wars in Iraq
and Afghanistan, and Yemen, Pakistan, and everywhere else, are clearly
– except to Christian
warmongers and imperial
Christians – unjust, immoral, and unnecessary, the only sensible
solution is to end the wars, not increase the defense budget.
Like other
Christian apologists for the state, its military, and its wars that
I have written
about who appeal to Romans 13 to justify their blind nationalism,
their cheerleading for the Republican Party, their childish devotion
to the military, their acceptance of national-security state, and
their support for perpetual war, Milton seeks to justify a large
defense budget by doing the same thing. This, of course, is ludicrous,
since the passage has nothing to do with the government providing
national defense. But let’s assume for a moment that it does. Fine.
How does that justify bloated military budgets, foreign wars, militarism,
imperialism, and policing the world? When it comes to the military
budget, conservatives adopt the same fallacy as liberals do when
it comes to education. To liberals more spending on education means
better education; to conservatives more spending on defense means
better defense.
And finally,
why do conservatives always invoke the name of the criminal,
warmongering, budget-busting, deficit-increasing, liberty-destroying,
government-expanding, economic and foreign interventionist St. Reagan?
Anyone remotely familiar with the Reagan record would not be impressed
with Milton’s name-dropping. For the complete and utter evisceration
of Reagan, see Murray Rothbard’s "The
Reagan Phenomenon," "Ronald
Reagan, Warmonger," and "Ronald
Reagan: An Autopsy."
What is so
bad about theological schizophrenics like Michael Milton is that
they have a position of influence over many young people. We can
only hope and pray that this is one college administrator that students
never get to know.
December
9, 2011
Laurence
M. Vance [send him mail]
writes from central Florida. He is the author of Christianity
and War and Other Essays Against the Warfare State, The
Revolution that Wasn't, and Rethinking
the Good War. His latest book is The
Quatercentenary of the King James Bible. Visit his
website.
Copyright
© 2011 by LewRockwell.com. Permission to reprint in whole or in
part is gladly granted, provided full credit is given.
The
Best of Laurence M. Vance
|